Tag Archive | puerto rico

Kinneretcon November 2018

A nice group of us attended the fourth Kinneretcon this year – Jon, Saarya, Tal, Robby, Gili, Eszter, Binyamin, Lorenzo, Haim, Nadine, Nadine F, Helen

Helen is a new gamer, she liked getting to learn new games, including Azul, Ticket to Ride and Pioneer Days.

Gili
In The Year of the Dragon, Stone Age, Kingsburg, Alchemists, Horizons, Luxor, Azul, Bears and Bees.

I liked Horizons, and it might be better with more players as Jon said. I also liked Luxor, a race game with hand management.

Jon

Key Flow: card game version of Keyflower. Not bad, but I miss the auction from Keyflower.

Unstable Unicorns: Very cute but godawful game.

Horizons: ho hum game of colonizing planets. Might be better with 3-4 players.

Pioneer Days: very good Euro from TMG with replayability.

Ex Libris: nice game of tile arranging with powers. Not punishing enough and might not be well-balanced, but correctable I think.

Lorenzo

Railroad Ink: nice short game for (in theory) an arbitrary number of players. No interaction between players, everyone should do the best with the same game options.

Blood Maison: investigative card game. Not the best luck/fun ratio imo.

Titan Race: racing game with dice drafting. Very direct interactions. Actually fun, especially for younger players.

Azul: nice as always

Ex Libris: design and mechanics are nice. However, too many moving options make the game less elegant. The huge number of combination of strategies and possibilities made me concerned about balance. Looking to try it again.

Scythe: I love this game.

Pioneer Days: very nice game. I thought I was doing well, but at the end I had not understood the game at all :).

Who Goes There?: the game that impressed me the most. It’s a survival co-op with the possibility that one player becomes “the enemy” in the middle of the game. Only negative is that you only know if the Bads or the Goods win at the end of the game. Still a great late night game.

Imaginarium: the pictures are great, but the game mechanic (card drafting, card combination and action selection) could be better.

Nadine

Ex Libris: An interesting game. Jon’s Trash Golem power was unbalanced, even though he didn’t win with it. I didn’t realize what was important for scoring, Lorenzo did and won. From a thread on bgg.com: I think that for the most part the balance is sufficient that you won’t see one character dominate every time out. That being said there are two that I felt were too strong and needed to be adjusted: the Bookworm and the Trash Golem. 

Herbaceous: I taught this to a few people as a filler, it’s a nice quick game, and pretty.

Scythe: My first play, I really liked the game. And did better than I expected to, partly because one of my missions was to get $20, which helped towards the scoring which is based on money. The 4 of us who were new had close scores, Lorenzo had twice as many points. It looks like a fighting and area control game, but there are other strategies with building and resource management.

Reef: A very simple game, which I managed to not do well at. It doesn’t seem as nice for kids as Takenoko.

Puerto Rico: I taught it to the one player who hadn’t played, and answered rules questions for the other two. I didn’t remember that Construction Hut is of no use when you take Settler yourself, the other players took early buildings that our group doesn’t take, such as Construction Hut, Hospice and Hacienda. Of course, the player with 3 Quarries won.

Lanterns: A nice game, but the score seemed related to turn order rather than quality of play. It’s tactical, the first player had 44 points, next one 43, and last one, me, 42. The scoring chips decrease as you go, so the first player advantage makes sense. Very pretty, quick and fun.

Firenze: After I decided to play, I realized that I had played before and hadn’t like it. I didn’t like it any better this time. Experience helps, but there is a lot of luck, which can be mitigated somewhat but not interesting to me.

Dinosaur Island: I taught this to Haim and another player. I didn’t remember the setup details well so it took a while. After we started the other player said that it’s not so complicated. Haim kept saying he had no idea what was going on, but he won. I shortened the game by one Objective card, and didn’t use the Hooligans.

Tichu: Various partners and partial games, always fun. Jon and Saarya played against me partnering Tal and Robby, we were winning after a few rounds when we stopped for dinner. Jon and I wanted to play against Roee and Zoya, who were taking turns with their 7-month-old, and then had to leave to get their other kids. Jon and I played against Zoya and Saarya, then Roee and Zoya, but only a few hands. Playing against Saarya, at the end of a GT I had called I played 2 fives and lost, my other card was a king, and I knew all the aces were out, but forgot right then.

Advertisements

Haim’s night

Magic

Jon+, David

Nefarious
Haim 20, Nadine 18, Jon 17, David 16, Aaron 13

Twists were: Lose a minion to invent, start game with 2 extra cards. Losing a minion turned out not to be as bad as it sounded.

Tikal

Haim 122, Jon 121, Nadine 104

I hadn’t played in years, and never with correct rules, not that I remembered. It’s a good game, pretty balanced though there is luck, and not my type of game. Jon had 3 sets of treasures, Chaim and I 2.

Azul

Lorenzo+, Aaron, David

Lorenzo had 1 column and 2 rows and all of one color

Puerto Rico B S B

Jon 21 26 13 60, Chaim 22 18 6 46, Nadine 20 16 9 45

We used a few of Jon’s buildings, Forest House, Beach House, Cathedral, Large Business, Assembly Line, Small Fashion District. I felt like everything was against me, even though I was the only one with coffee for a while. Jon bought Large Business early, and a Large Market, Small Market wasn’t in the game.

Tichu

Aaron / Nadine+, Jon / Haim

On the last hand, I had an Ace, King bomb, Phoenix which fit into 3 consecutive pairs to jacks, 2, 3, 9. I was planning on calling Tichu. Aaron led the 1 and called and Ace. Jon played the 8, and I decided not to call Tichu. I led the 2, Haim called Tichu, won with an ace, and played a straight. Then he played a single card which let me get rid of my 9; I bombed his dragon and my consecutive pairs won. Aaron also passed the dog to Jon, which he played to Haim. We made two GTs, they made one, going out one two. We had two bombs to block a Tichu that Jon called.

 

My big fat PR mistake!

We played at Galit’s place for the first time because she’s housebound.

Azul

Galit has this and knows how to play, it’s been winning awards and being lauded for gameplay, graphics and components. The pieces are really nice, beautiful small tiles, with a Portuguese decorated tile theme. Very abstract, but fun. David thought more than I did but once you understand it, there aren’t that many options. We stopped when Nadine F (previously S) and Noam came. Galit paints her own tiles for her walls.

Puerto Rico

David 26 15 15 56.2  Nadine 16 30 46.5  Noam 12 34 46.2 Galit 11 27 7 45.4 Nadine F 15 20 7 42.3

We stayed where we had been sitting – my big mistake, because I was after David. David was after two new players, who were not paying attention to anyone else. David was paying attention to everyone, but saw me as his main competition so really blocked me. I’m not used to that type of blocking; we haven’t been playing PR that much at his level because we mainly play with new players. I said Jon doesn’t block like he does, but that may not be true – I’ve remembered to arrange seating when playing against him, though I did sit behind him once. David agreed that seating order makes a significant difference. David thought that I was doing better than I was, I knew that my shipping and no large building wasn’t going to beat his 3 large buildings.

Play was slow with new players who are good gamers and wanted to understand everything. David blocked me from trading early on, Nadine F blocked him accidentally when she crafted and he couldn’t get goods. David had coffee and I had tobacco. He took a factory a round or two before I did. He later took tobacco which gave him 5 each round to my 3, and landed me with a useless sugar. He also took Customs House, but by then I had been taking captain instead of trader so didn’t have money anyway. I had a wharf, but wasn’t producing so many goods. Noam also had a wharf and took craftsman a lot to get extra goods, he even double crafted when there were barely any goods left, no one had harbor. Nadine F has played twice before, but was last too often in trading, shipping and captain, partly because she took mayor a lot. She did get fortress, and Galit had Residence, she had taken Hacienda early on. She had all the indigo in her small warehouse which reduced money for me and David. The game is still fun and the best game!

New Players

Parade

Jon 10, Haim 19, Amir 23, Nadine 23

Ticket to Ride

Gili 171, Tzvi 140, Amir 86

Taught by Gili.

Puerto Rico

B S B T Nadine 14 39 9 60, Haim 24 23 11 57, Jon 21 23 12 56

We were all surprised that I won, and that Jon came in last – we all thought Jon was winning, especially during the first half of the game. Jon and Haim had factories early, before their coffee buildings. I had a tobacco monopoly once I finally got it, and took the 6 ship for it. I kept producing which gave Jon and Haim tons of money, Haim had 17 even after getting a big building, Jon had about 13. I focused on producing and shipping because I had no money; I took Customs House after Jon took Guild Hall, he also had Fortress, Haim had the other two. When Haim bought a Large Warehouse mid-game, Jon said it wasn’t worth it in a 3-player game, and we let Haim switch. During the game he tossed at least 5 goods that he would have kept with LW. Jon tossed a few more goods than I did, we didn’t have warehouses. So Haim might have won with LW. Jon had Harbor. Jon thinks we may have made mistakes with my shipping points, I don’t think so but it’s frustrating not to be sure – Jon usually has a good sense of what’s going on in games, better than I do. Haim keeps requesting to play this so he can improve, he did very well and we may stop giving him corn to start.

Nefarious

Jon+, Haim, Allegra

Twists: Double card effects, Can’t take the same two actions in a row. First play for Allegra, who seemed to catch the spirit of the game when she enjoyed causing the other two to each lose 6 dollars. Jon got to 20 with an invention that gave points for his other inventions.

Notre Dame

Nadine 49, Gili 42, Zvi 39

Zvi’s first play. Gili and I were competing, she didn’t get cards she needed at one point.

Crokinole x 2

Haim, Jon, Allegra

Lag B’Omer

We had to keep all the windows closed due to smoke outside from the holiday bonfires.

Love Letter

Haim won two games to my one, then Gili arrived and won a game. We stopped playing the next game when Lorenzo arrived, I guessed Gili’s card at the beginning so she was already out.

Puerto Rico

Lorenzo 17 40 5 62, Gili 22 28 7 57, Nadine 21 22 12 54, Haim 18 21 6 45 (Buildings, Shipping, Bonus, Total)

Haim wants to keep playing this until he understands it better, rather than learning new games all the time. Gili doesn’t usually like it, but said she hadn’t played in a long time so was willing to try, and afterwards said she liked it better this time. I went first, then Haim, then Gili, then Lorenzo. The game is always fun and interesting. Gili had wharf and factory and produced all goods except sugar. Lorenzo had wharf and harbor and a coffee monopoly for most of the game, he got a lot of points from the harbor. I had factory and two large buildings, the others had one. Haim had large market and large warehouse by the end, but no storage most of the game.

Lo Ra

Lorenzo 32, Haim 25, Nadine 17, Gili 16

Lorenzo did well with tribes, and got the ark, Gili had most baskets til the last round.

More 5-player PR

Puerto Rico

Nadine 34 17 8 59, Jon 20 23 13 56.10, Aaron 28 17 5 56.5, Nadine S 22 17 7 46, Haim 27 13 0 40  (Buildings, Shipping, Bonus, Total)

5-player Puerto Rico again, and I won again, and not on a tie, after last time seeming like a fluke. Seating: Jon, Nadine, Haim, Aaron, Nadine S. Beforehand Haim switched places with me because Jon said second is the worst position; Jon offered to switch but I said I want to win as second. He gave the least experienced players corn. I had factory, wharf, 3 corns, 1 indigo, 1 tobacco behind Jon, and managed to get Customs House. Jon had 2 big buildings including Guild Hall.

Tichu

Aaron Nadine 1000+, Jon Haim 505

We had much better cards and won in a few rounds.

Passover Games Day 5778

A busy games day, with most people staying the whole time. Thanks to those who came early and stayed late to help with set-up and clean-up – Nechemia, Assaf, Lior, Binyamin and Jon, who also brought an extra table and chairs; and to Gili for the pictures she took and for organizing the online dinner order. Quite a few close games, a crazy Tichu game, and even a few hands of bridge, and welcome to Lorenzo’s wife Sara. Game trend – titles that begin with the letter C. Played more than once: Crokinole, Oh My Goods, Tichu, Traders of Osaka.

Alchemists

Binyamin 27, Haley 21, Eszter 12, Gili 11

Bridge

Nadine and Binyamin S, Jon and Binyamin

Binyamin really wanted to play, Binyamin S has never played so we walked him through. First hand I opened 3 spades with 7, Binyamin S passed, and Jon and Binyamin made game in hearts. Next games I bid and Binyamin passed, Jon and Binyamin went one down in 4 spades with Binyamin playing it, I had a strong hand.

Catan

Azriel+, Lorenzo, Binyamin, Eszter

Clans of Caledonia

Nechemia 130, Sara 120, Nadine 108, Assaf B 103

First play for the other three. We played with 4 points per all import goods, with no tracking or coins for them. I tried the delta clan, which did help somewhat, partly because being near rivers helped me get most settlements, and I upgraded to two lochs which I usually don’t do. Nechemia had the whiskey clan, Sara had double contracts, and Assaf had the one with the extra initial placement. Nechemia tied Sara for most contracts with 5, and had 72 in export good points. I had a lot of whiskey at the end that I didn’t have market tokens to sell, I should have done more market upgrades in the last round.

Codenames

Eszter, Binyamin S, Efrat, Gili, Noam, Maria

They played three rounds.

Concordia

Binyamin, Rosalynn, Nechemia, Yehuda K

Not Rosalynn’s type of game, not sure it’s mine either though I heard it’s good. Nadine S left to join Walnut Grove.

Crokinole 

Jon, Elianna, Rosalynn and others throughout the day. Jon:  Crokinole, not too much play, but some fun play nonetheless. Binyamin didn’t take to it, and especially not the high price I paid for the game.

Deep Sea Adventure

Lorenzo, Binyamin S, Azriel

Dinosaur Island

Jon 79, Lior 77, Gili 74, Efrat 71

Jon complained a lot about the Hooligan mechanic, which adds total luck to a strategy game. It doesn’t have that big of an effect and the luck sometimes evens out, but annoying nevertheless, Gili likes it because it adds fun and suspense.

Jon: A game with somewhat confusing graphics, but straightforward gameplay. As I mentioned several times during the game, the game has a bunch of random and strategic elements, which are fine, but then ends with a luck draw out of a bag that serves absolutely no game purpose other than to screw some people instead of others (much like Thebes). In some games there may be a person or development that you can buy to mitigate it, but often not, and only one person would be able to do it. And there is no, absolutely no, purpose for the mechanic. It is as useful as simply rolling a die and handing out victory points based on the number you roll – actually, it is exactly like that. Remove the mechanic and the game plays EXACTLY the same, but far better. I like the game other than that. It’s a basic planning and allotment of resources game that works well enough with enough theme to color it.

Hansa Teutonica

Jon, Avi, Efrat, Lior

Jon: Enjoyed by all players. I didn’t take any of the instant circle bonuses, like I usually do. Instead, the game ended rather quickly as Avi and I spread a network of cities across much of the left two-thirds of the board. I had a boost from having 4 disks, while one other person had any, and only one.

Homesteaders

Efrat 54, Lior 49, Gili 34

First time for all players.

Lewis & Clark

Nadine+, Lorenzo, Yokhay

First play for Lorenzo and Chaim. I’m starting to understand the game, first time I played with the rule where you can discard cards to pay equipment, we had missed it until now and it makes a difference. Fewer cards were bought than in previous games I’ve played, I only bought one, a 3, which helped, but my main advantage was it being their first play. Lorenzo bought the card I wanted at the start, but then gave me good advice. Lorenzo hogged the Indians, there were a few times where there were none available at all. We shortened the trail by 7 spaces to finish sooner, which may have hurt them with a stronger infrastructure.

Mercator

Nadine S 44, Adrien 41, Avi 34, Elianna 33

New to all of them. Jon wanted to try this again, but after teaching it ended up trying Alchemists, which he also didn’t play in the end.

Nefarious

Jon 20, Binyamin, Binyamin S, Haley

Oh My Goods

Lorenzo 25, 24 Binyamin S 24, Eszter 21

Rosalynn, Elianna and Azriel also played.

Puerto Rico

Noam 54, Yael 50, Yossi 48, Maria 46, Assaf B 39

Rising Sun

Yael, Yehuda K, Avi, Binyamin, Yossi

Yael taught this, they played a long time but didn’t finish the game.

Tichu

Jon and Lior, Azriel and Binyamin S played a hand or two earlier.

Avi and Nadine vs Assaf B and Yehuda Klein

First game
300 -100
600 -100
635 -35
935 -35
1100 0

Second game, which we didn’t finish
40 -40
100 0
405 -5

I called Tichu at least 3 times in the first game. Avi offered to switch partners after the first game, but they said no. It was mostly luck of the cards, though Yehuda K hadn’t realized he could play his 4 bomb over my 3 bomb. It might have stopped my Tichu but he couldn’t have gone out easily. I played something like the 1, 3, Queen, 3 bomb and a 7-card straight with the Phoenix.

Traders of Osaka

Jon, Lior, Efrat

Jon, Binyamin, Nechemia

Jon: It played well enough, but it’s just a bit too long for what it is, which keeps it from being a far better experience. There is often just a little more to the gameplay then there seems to be, however.

Tzolk’in

Nechemia 63, Sara 58, Assaf B 57, Rosalynn 33

New to all of them.

Walnut Grove

Nadine 29, Nadine S 25, Yochai 24, Elianna 18

First play for all but me. I lost 6 points on the last turn – I couldn’t pay 3 cubes, and only had 2 left – not enough to pay back a loan, so I had to take two Neighborly Helps and used a gold coin, but I had 3 bonus tiles which made the difference, two 2-point per bonus tiles for 12; Nadine S had 2 and the others one.

Yinsh

Jon+, Nechemia

Passover Games Day East – April 4

Jon went to visit David in Maale Adumim because David isn’t attending public gaming events while in avelut. Report by Jon:

David and I and two of his kids played Nefarious. We had the twists a) when you research, draw two cards and then toss a card, and b) you gain 1 vp for every 5 coins you have. Everything was pretty normal, until both of the kids got to 21 on one round. David had 20 and I had 19. So we went another round. Both kids had 22 and I got to 22, as well. The next round two people had 23. The next round two people had 24. The next round two people had 25, but I got to 26 and won.

We all played Tichu for a while, and my partner and I went very negative. We were -350 to 350 at one point. We stopped for dinner when my side was -170 to 570.

After dinner, David, Avi, and I played Lewis & Clark. Probably not the right game for David, even though he loves it. It’s a real analysis paralysis machine, as you know, and David took a long time on his very first turn. So did Avi. I was patient. Eventually, David got ahead of us, Avi eventually started playing faster just because he didn’t want to think too long, and we all make some of those famous mistakes, which is the point I think. David won several rounds ahead of any of us. They both enjoyed it, but agreed that maybe David shouldn’t play it.