Participants: Jon, Zachary, Jessica, Gili, Aryeh, Binyamin, Nadine
Aryeh is a first-timer to the club. He has a little game experience.
Heroes of Graxia
Jessica 26, Zachary 21, Gili 21
I started this game but then left as it started to play with Aryeh. This was our first game actually finished, with most of the rules played correctly. However, we made the big mistake (at least until halfway through) of not discarding our hands and drawing a new one (ala Dominion). We were playing that you had to spend actions to draw cards. Of course, this changes the game dramatically.
I don’t know what they did when they discovered this error. I know that Jessica had most of her legion decimated near the end of the game but still won the game.
Binyamin 55,600, Jon 51,400, Aryeh 48,400
First play for Aryeh, and somewhere in the single digits for Binyamin. Aryeh was, without a doubt, the slowest player in our group, ever (yes, even slower then you, David). It was kind of a mystery, since he was obviously bright. He hesitated, asked a question about something minute, hesitated, asked another question about some minute aspect of strategy, hesitated, and then hesitated more. It seemed was very hard for him to make a decision, even when he had only one good option, but especially when he had nothing particularly good to do and simply had to place some random tile. The game took nearly three hours, of which 2.5 hours at least was Aryeh. I was growing restless, and I knew that Binyamin was going nuts.
He began to speed up a little near the end, but only marginally. And yet, other than his slowness, he was a nice guy and could be fun to play with. I think the trick is to find the right games for his personality type.
In our game, I managed to avoid the problem I had last game of only buying edge properties which took a long time to merge. I had spending cash all game. Binyamin and Aryeh were low on cash at least once each. But I still didn’t win, mostly because I had fewer shares of the two big chains at the end. I made more money initially, but Binyamin managed a few quick foundings and mergers at the end.
Jessica 48, Gili 43, Nadine 41, Zachary 32
Gili suggested this, I think. First plays for Jessica and Zachary. It took a long time, too, I think.
Jessica, Gili, Nadine, Zachary
Played as a filler.
Binyamin+ (Detective), Jon (Criminal)
Binyamin caught Mr Jack on round 6, after a tipoff from the red guy. Also played as a filler.
Jon 63, Nadine 49, Jessica 6, Binyamin 0
I taught this to Binyamin and Jessica. I’ve figure out now to teach it starting backwards, from the score to the points, and then from the bid to the score. And then to the play. The reasons and strategy for bidding are still a complete mystery for the first 10 or 20 hands you play. But they began to warm up to it by the end of the two hands we played.