Participants: Jon, Nadine, Jonathan, Gili, Yitzchak, Shirley, David K
Gili and Binyamin were absent last week attempting to teach some non-gamers how to play Settlers, apparently without much success.
Princes of Florence
Jonathan 63, Nadine 62, Yitzchak 61, Gili 58
I set this up, but then moved to another game and Nadine took my place. The scores are really close, as you can see, and this was Jonathan’s first game.
David 116, Jon 68, Shirley 68
Shirley’s first game. I generally don’t like playing this, as it takes too long and is too fiddly. And, when you know you’re losing, you get to know that for a few hours. That’s what happened here. I had a nice second round, but the Provost kept knocking out everything I wanted to do, and David was just miles ahead structurally by mid-game.
At one point, I had the decision to move the provost back up 1 to 3 spaces, but I was only considering the space nearest to the Provost, and what would happen if David moved it back to that spot. I decided that the space didn’t matter enough, but I would let David decide. I missed the fact that he could move it three spaces, knocking out two of mine. It was a 10 point loss for me (no building in the castle, no favor) and a large loss in momentum, too. And it hurt Shirley prettily, too.
It was just a matter of how much he would win by. A lot, as you can see.
Yitzchak 71, Nadine 58, Jonathan 56
Another first game for Jonathan, but he didn’t fare quite as well (though decent enough).
Magic: The Gathering
We simply cut 60 cards for each player from the stack of remaining unplayed cards, eliminating a few of the duplicates. Without drafting, one doesn’t feel like one has as much to do with one’s own success. In this case, David had the better deck. Building and playing still have a lot to do, but not enough.
I won the first game only because David was stuck at two lands for nearly all of it. And it was still close.
[DK: Well close is an exaggeration. I was holding my own, which was very surprising for only two mana over many many rounds. Jon neglected to mention that my two mana was after a mulligan down to 6 cards since my first draw was mana short. And this was with a 40 card deck with 17 mana.]
The second game wasn’t a walkover for David; I managed to bury three of his creatures. But he had more ways of delivering the pain than I did.