Participants: Jon, Yitzchak, Nadine, Adam, Gili, Ben
Nadine returns from chu”l. She played games at Yahoo’s HQ in California with South Bay Boardgamers (San Juan and Aladdin’s Dragons) and met someone who had already ordered It’s Alive.
Princes of Florence
Ben 79, Nadine, Yitzchak
Ben won by around ten points over Nadine and Yitzchak, one of whom had one more point than the other, but I forget which one. That’s what comes from not writing down the scores.
At one point, someone here expressed a desire to be allowed to move the buildings around after they have been placed, an idea at which Adam scoffed at as unrealistic.
Gili 37, Jon 29, Adam 19
Again, scores are approximate. This was a rambling and full game, with a long river, a lot of gold mined, and a lot of explored territory. Gili stole from some of the work that Adam did. That should have been to my advantage, but my lack of equipment slowed me down. I had previous experiences of the game ending too quickly and so I didn’t want to waste the time in investing. Since the game lasted for some time, my lack of investment hurt.
I eventually went back and got a boat, which is really nice. Gili had a cart, which is about as nice. I think both, plus fishing rod and axe, is probably the best set of tools.
It was pretty obvious that Gili was winning already with the last quarter of the game to go. I think that the biggest negative is picking a single or double gold nugget from an event, which is nigh useless.
We still have some rule issues. Can people drop or sell back equipment, for instance? And the rules for how and where you can lay out territory are still confusing. When you are required to add a water tile is confusing. Can you collect river gold if you are on the wrong side of a river but own a boat? And other issues that keep coming up.
At one point, Gili expressed a desire to be allowed to move mines around after they have been placed, an idea at which Adam scoffed at as unrealistic.
Jon 537, Adam 532, Gili
I think this is my first victory. Unlike other auction games, I think this game is better with three than with four or five, as you have more control and more chances to lay down cards, instead of being at the whim of what everyone else decides.
We played a number of hands of this, and I got a lot of 4333 average hands. I also tried playing Bridge together with Modern Art, but that didn’t work out too well.
We played on an 11×11 board, and even with handicap stones, it’s clear that I am just not good enough to challenge Adam, yet. I need to go back and learn some basics again.